8 article(s) will be saved.
EBSCO Publishing Citation Format:
MLA (Modern Language Assoc.):
NOTE: Review the instructions at http://support.ebsco.com/help/?int=ehost&lang=&feature_id=MLA
and make any necessary corrections before using. Pay special attention
to personal names, capitalization, and dates. Always consult your
library resources for the exact formatting and punctuation guidelines.
Works Cited"And Furthermore." Teacher Librarian 31.1 (2003): 55-58. Canadian Reference Centre. EBSCO. Web. 18 Dec. 2009.
Richards, Jan "Frontline." inCite 30.10 (2009): 4. Library, Information Science & Technology Abstracts. EBSCO. Web. 18 Dec. 2009.
Sykes,
Judith "Implementation Thoughts at the District Level: Achieving
Information Literacy--Standards for School Library Programs in Canada."
School Libraries in Canada 23.1 (2003): 26. Canadian Reference Centre. EBSCO. Web. 18 Dec. 2009.
Koechlin, Carol, and Sandi Zwaan "Making library programs count: Where's the evidence?." School Libraries in Canada 22.2 (2002): 21. Canadian Reference Centre. EBSCO. Web. 18 Dec. 2009.
Abram, Stephen "Once More with Feeling: What Does Information Literacy Look Like in the Google World?." MultiMedia & Internet@Schools 12.3 (2005): 18-20. Canadian Reference Centre. EBSCO. Web. 18 Dec. 2009.
Manzo, Kathleen Kennedy "Study Shows Rise in Test Scores Tied to School Library Resources." Education Week 19.28 (2000): 27. Academic Search Premier. EBSCO. Web. 18 Dec. 2009.
Oberg, Dianne "The Crisis in School Libraries: The Case for Reform and Re-Investment." Canadian Journal of Information & Library Sciences 28.4 (2004): 117-119. Library, Information Science & Technology Abstracts. EBSCO. Web. 18 Dec. 2009.
Farquharson, Michele "the power of high quality school library programs." Teacher Librarian 36.5 (2009): 85-86. Academic Search Premier. EBSCO. Web. 18 Dec. 2009.
<!--Additional Information:
Persistent link to this record (Permalink): http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=rch&AN=12123791&site=ehost-live
End of citation--><!--Additional Information:
Persistent link to this record (Permalink): http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=lxh&AN=44638695&site=ehost-live
End of citation-->
<!--Additional Information:
Persistent link to this record (Permalink): http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=rch&AN=11114841&site=ehost-live
End of citation-->
<!--Additional Information:
Persistent link to this record (Permalink): http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=rch&AN=8561121&site=ehost-live
End of citation-->
<!--Additional Information:
Persistent link to this record (Permalink): http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=rch&AN=17152025&site=ehost-live
End of citation-->
<!--Additional Information:
Persistent link to this record (Permalink): http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=aph&AN=3153718&site=ehost-live
End of citation-->
<!--Additional Information:
Persistent link to this record (Permalink): http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=lxh&AN=19872906&site=ehost-live
End of citation-->
<!--Additional Information:
Persistent link to this record (Permalink): http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=aph&AN=41688122&site=ehost-live
End of citation-->
And Furthermore
Canada's School Libraries in Crisis
A new report by Dr. Ken Haycock asserts
Canada's school libraries are at a critical turning point, facing a
major crisis due to years of under-funding. Dr. Haycock, publisher and
executive editor of Teacher Librarian and professor in the School of
Library, Archival and Information Studies at The University of British
Columbia, was commissioned to study the state of Canada's school
libraries by the Association of Canadian Publishers. The report, The
Crisis in Canada's School Libraries: The Case for Reform and
Re-Investment, is available online at http://www.publishers.ca/pages/HaycockACP2%5fv2rev%20FINAL.pdf.
The study was written with the support of a review committee from the
Canadian Coalition for School Libraries (CCSL). The review committee
consisted of members from the Association of Canadian Publishers, the
Canadian Children's Book Centre, the Ontario Library Association,
People for Education and the Association for Teacher-Librarianship in
Canada.
The study calls for a massive injection of
funds for school libraries, to make up for the years of severe cuts
that have been imposed by cash-strapped provincial governments.
According to the report, "Canada's school
libraries are not at their best; far from it. Across the country,
teacher-librarians are losing their jobs or being reassigned.
Collections are becoming depleted owing to budget cuts. Some principals
believe that in the age of the Internet and the classroom workstation,
the school library is an artifact." Noting that many other countries
are recognizing the importance of school libraries and restoring
funding, Haycock's report draws together the empirical evidence showing
the positive and measurable impact teacher-librarians and a well-funded
school library program can have on student performance levels.
Kent State Awarded $2 Million for Collaboration Project
Kent State University has received $2 million in federal funds for a new library education project.
US Representative Ralph Regula (R-OH),
Chairman of the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Labor, Health and
Human Services and Education, announced the project funding. "I am
pleased to have been able to include federal funding for Kent State
University to demonstrate how school librarians and classroom teachers
can work together to enrich the curriculum of students. I am hopeful
that the demonstration of this collaborative work will be used as a
model to enhance the learning environment," Regula explained.
The institute will provide leadership in
developing coordinated collaboration among K-12 teachers and
teacher-librarians who are concerned with advancing library and
information literacy in the school curriculum.
Report Assesses Grade 4 Reading Skills
A major new international literacy study is
now available online. Released by the National Center for Education
Statistics, International comparisons in fourth-grade reading literacy:
Findings from the Progress in International Reading Literacy Study
(PIRLS) of 2001 describes the reading literacy of Grade 4 students in
35 countries. The report provides information on a variety of reading
topics and compares average scores across the 35 countries on reading
scales, as well as achievement broken out by sex. Within the US,
comparisons by race/ethnicity, by public and private schools, and by
poverty levels of the school are given. The full report can be
downloaded as a PDF file from http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2003073.
Among the findings: US students were ahead of
their counterparts in 23 of the 34 other participating countries. The
report also confirms a trend teachers and parents often note
anecdotally: girls outperformed boys in all 35 countries.
Not yet available in print, the report also
defines reading literacy for Grade 4, presents information on reading
and instruction in the classroom and explores the reading habits of
Grade 4 students outside of school.
New School Library Award
The International Association of School
Librarianship (IASL) announces a new award for teacher-librarians,
educators and/or researchers that recognizes significant contributions
to school librarianship. The $1,000 award will be made for the first
time in 2004 to an individual or team nominated by their professional
associations and peers.
Sponsored by Softlink International
(Australia), this award will take into consideration the significance
of the nominee's achievement in relation to resource context, evidence
of commitment to school librarianship, impact on student learning and
contribution to professional development of others. Preference will be
given to members of IASL. The award will be determined by an
international awards panel.
Information about membership and the Softlink
Excellence award is available from the IASL Secretariat, via mail: Box
34069, Department 962, Seattle, WA 98124-1069; telephone: 604-925-0266;
fax: 604-925-0566; e-mail: iasl@rockland.com; or online at www.iasl-slo.org.
AASL 2003 Awards Recipients
The American Association of School Librarians (AASL) has announced the 2003 awards recipients.
The AASL Collaborative School Library Media
Award of $2,500 was awarded to teacher-librarian Leslie Preddy of Perry
Meridian Middle School, Indianapolis, IN, along with teachers Howard
Ely, Cathy Littleton, Jenny Moore and Stephanie Quinlan. The
Collaborative School Library Media Award, sponsored by the Sagebrush
Corporation, recognizes and encourages collaboration and partnerships
between teacher-librarians and teachers in meeting goals outlined in
Information power: Building partnerships for learning through joint
planning of a program, unit or event in support of the curriculum and
using school library resources.
The AASL/Highsmith Research Grant has been
awarded to Bonnie Grimble of Carmel High School in Carmel, IN, for her
proposed study, Teachers' Perspectives and Influence on Use of
Electronic Resources in the High School Media Center. The grant,
sponsored by Highsmith Co., Inc., was established in 1993. Winners
receive up to $5,000 to conduct innovative research aimed at measuring
and evaluating the impact of school library resource programs on
learning and education.
The ABC-CLIO Leadership Grant of up to $1,750
is given to school library associations that are AASL affiliates for
planning and implementing leadership programs at the state, regional or
local levels. The 2003 grant, donated by ABC-CLIO Schools, has been
awarded to the Minnesota Educational Media Organization.
Barbara E. De Spain, principal of Lois Lenski
Elementary School in Centennial, CO, is the recipient of the
Distinguished School Administrator Award, sponsored by SIRS. An award
of $2,000 is given to a school administrator who has made worthy
contributions to the operations of an exemplary school library resource
center and to advancing the role of the school library resource center
in the educational program.
The Frances Henne Award has been awarded to
Teresa Diaz of Johnston High School in Austin, TX. The award, sponsored
by Greenwood Publishing Group, is awarded to a teacher-librarian with
five or fewer years in the field, to attend an American Library
Association (ALA) Annual Conference or AASL National Conference for the
first time.
The Information Technology Pathfinder Award,
sponsored by Follett Software, was awarded in the secondary category to
Sarah McElrath of the Lakeshore Middle School in Grand Haven, MI. The
$1,250 award recognizes teacher-librarians demonstrating vision and
leadership through the use of information technology to build lifelong
learners. The elementary category was not awarded this year.
The National School Library Media Program of
the Year Award is sponsored by Follett Library Resources. Winners
receive a crystal obelisk and $10,000 in each of the three categories.
The award recognizes large and small school districts and a single
school for exemplary school library resource programs that are fully
integrated into the school's curriculum. The 2003 award has been
awarded to Millard Public School District in Omaha, NE, for the Large
School District category. Winner in the Small School District category
was Liberty Public School District in Liberty, MO, and Cherry Creek
High School in Greenwood, CO, won in the Single School category. More
information about this year's award recipients is available on the AASL
Web site.
Teen Read Week Focuses on Poetry
What do music lyrics, writing, poetry slams,
and open mic nights have in common? They encourage teens to read poetry
for the fun of it! This year's Teen Read Week celebrates poetry,
October 19-25, 2003. Hundreds of libraries, schools and bookstores are
encouraging teens to "read for the fun of it" as they celebrate this
year's poetry-centric Teen Read Week theme, SLAMMIN' @ your library.
Teen Read Week is the national adolescent
literacy initiative of the Young Adult Library Services Association, a
division of ALA. More resources can be found at the association's Teen
Read Week web site: www.ala.org/teenread.
Some of the ways school libraries can encourage teens to celebrate Teen Read Week:
• Encourage teens to read and write poetry.
• Offer a book discussion group.
• Invite teens to orally interpret poetic song lyrics.
• Suggest teens keep a poetry book in their
backpack at all times. Tell them to read it while waiting for the bus,
an appointment or friends to pick them up.
• Add a (or add another) poetry book or novel written in poetic form to your collection.
• Encourage teens to read what they want to read, just for the fun of it.
Children's Book Week Celebrates Freedom
Reading is a right! Free to Read, this year's
theme for the 84th observance of The Children's Book Council's
Children's Book Week, encourages children, and the adults who care for
them, to exercise their right to read right by spending some time with
a book each day. Children's Book Week 2003 is November 17-23.
Teacher-librarians can find resources to help schools celebrate
Children's Book Week at the CBC web site, www.cbcbooks.org/html/book%5fweek.html.
Since 1919, educators, librarians,
booksellers and families have celebrated Children's Book Week during
the week before Thanksgiving. Book Week events are held in schools,
libraries, bookstores, clubs, private homes--any place where there are
children and books.
US Kids' Book Production Tops 10,000 in 2002
Book production in the United States jumped
six percent in 2002, with 150,000 new titles and editions released.
Production of books for children jumped to its highest level ever, with
more than 10,000 titles published.
The statistics were compiled by R.R. Bowker,
using data from its Books in Print® database. Overall, general adult
fiction continued to be the strongest category, again topping 17,000
new titles and editions in 2002. The large trade publishers released
significantly fewer books in the adult fiction and travel categories,
many more business books, and about the same number of juvenile and
young adult titles. University presses, not surprisingly, published
more books in the history, sociology and economics categories, but also
published more business and poetry books.
Prices in all categories increased, with the average suggested retail price of a children's hardcover book in 2002 at $15.93.
Other interesting statistics in Bowker's report:
10,305 new publishers came on the scene in
2002. Like the large trade houses, adult fiction was the most popular
category, accounting for 15% percent of new titles from these
publishers. Other strong categories were religious and inspirational,
poetry and books for children.
Publishers declared 131,611 books out-of-print or out-of-stock indefinitely in 2002, an increase of 6% percent over 2001.
Metasearch Engine Offers Deep Web Access
London-based search engine Turbol0 (http://turbo10.com) has unveiled technology connecting to over 1,000 topic-specific engines on the Internet.
Originally presented at the 12th
International World Wide Web Conference in Budapest, this technology is
the first fully automated system that creates and maintains connections
to online databases en masse. The current list of more than 1000
engines can be viewed at http://turbo10.com/cgibin/showdeepnet.cgi. The list is updated every five minutes as more engines are added.
Details of this new technology are discussed
in a technical paper titled "The mechanics of a deep net metasearch
engine." It is available online at http://turbo10.com/papers/deepnet.pdf.
New Report Compares Education in G-8 Nations
The National Center for Education Statistics
has released a new report on education in the G-8 countries, comparing
the US education system to those in Canada, France, Germany, Italy,
Japan, the Russia Federation and the United Kingdom.
The report looks at in five areas: (1) the
context of education; (2) preprimary and primary education; (3)
secondary education; (4) higher education; and (5) education and the
labor force. Among the findings:
The United States was one of only three G8
countries (along with Germany and the UK) whose school-age population
grew in absolute number between 1992 and 1999.
In 1999, the proportion of adults who
completed at least an upper secondary education was higher in the US
than in the six other countries presented.
In 1999, enrollment rates of children ages 3
to 5 in preprimary education were lower in the United States than in
France, Germany, Italy and Japan.
In 2000, American 15 year olds had lower
average scores than their Canadian counterparts on the PISA reading
literacy scale, but no difference was detected compared to the
performance of 15 year olds in France, Italy, Germany, Japan or the UK.
Drawing on the most current information
available about education, Comparative Indicators of Education in the
United States and Other G8 Countries: 2002 is available for free
downloading as a 141-page PDF document, at http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2003026.
Our Columnists
Marlene Asselin: Associate professor, Faculty of Education, The University of British Columbia, Vancouver. marlene.asselin@ubc.ca
Barbara Braxton: Teacher-librarian, Palmerston District Primary School, Palmerston, Australian Capital Territory. barbara@austarmetro.com.au
Rosemary Chance: Assistant
professor School of Library and Information Science, University of
Southern Mississippi, Hattiesburg. rosemary.chance@usm.edu
Anne Clyde: Professor, Faculty of Social Science, The University of Iceland, Reykjavik. anne@hi.is
Ruth Cox: Assistant professor, School of Education, University of Houston-Clear Lake, Houston. cox@cl.uh.edu
Susan Faust: Teacher-librarian, Katherine Delmar Burke School, San Francisco. susan.f@kdbs.org
Reid Goldsborough: Author of Straight talk about the information superhighway. reidgold@netaxs.com http://members.home.net/reidgold
Holly Gunn: Teacher-librarian, Sackville High School, Sackville, NS. hgunn@accesscable.net
Teri Lesesne: Assistant professor, Department of Library Science, Sam Houston State University, Huntsville, TX. lis_tsl@shsu.edu
Kate Houston Mitchoff: School Corps Librarian, Multnomah County Library, Portland, OR. kateho@yahoo.com
Ann Riedling: Associate Professor St. Leo University, Director, St. Petersburg Campus, Seminole, FL. ariedling@iglou.com
Joanne Troutner: Director
of Media/Technology, Tippecanoe School Corp, and owner, Creative
Computer Enterprises, Lafayette, IN. troutner@mindspring.com www.jtroutner.com/
Helen Wiley: Teacher-librarian, Katherine Delmar Burke School, San Francisco. helen@kdbs.org
Robert Wilson: Director/Head Teacher, Moccasin Community Day School, Groveland, CA. coltrane@lodelink.com
Copyright
of Teacher Librarian is the property of Scarecrow Press Inc. and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a
listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission.
However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual
use.
Section: THE PIPELINE
Once More with Feeling: What Does Information Literacy Look Like in the Google World?
ACCORDING to the Association of
Teacher-Librarians in Canada (now called the Canadian Association of
School Libraries), students, to become lifelong learners, must be able
to do the following:
* Recognize the need for information to solve problems and develop ideas.
* Pose important questions.
* Use a variety of information gathering strategies and research processes.
* Locate relevant and appropriate information.
* Access information for quality, authority, accuracy and authenticity.
* Use the practical and conceptual tools of information technology.
* Understand form and format of information, location and access methods, including how information is situated and produced.
* Format and publish in text and multimedia, adapting to emerging technologies.
--From Information Studies, Kindergarten to Grade 12: Curriculum for Schools and School Library Information Centres
Seems simple enough--these are pretty clear
graduation outcomes. But what does it really mean in grade 1? Grade 3?
Grade 9? I personally like and admire the work done in my province and
provincial school libraries association, where we code our expectations
of our learners and help them build their information literacy skills
in a planned and effective manner. Each stage of life and school comes
with its own set of new skills requirements to achieve success across
the curriculum. This curriculum recognizes the need for and importance
of these types of learning opportunities:
* Formal and informal programs to encourage the transfer of information literacy skills and knowledge to real-life situations
* An information problem-solving process, as well as specific information application skills
* A research process to develop higher-order critical and creative thinking skills
* Expertise in the use of the tools and
applications of the Information Age, from traditional print to digital
information technologies
* The development of student independence in using information for lifelong learning
* The use of information-based decision-making and decision-making to enhance life at school, at work, and at home
* The collaborative role of parents,
teachers, and teacher-librarians in promoting independent thinking and
information problem-solving
* The development of safe, ethical and responsible practices in acquiring, using, and communicating information
* The integration of a wide range of activities and resources to provide a lifetime of reading and learning
--From Information Studies, Kindergarten to Grade 12: Curriculum for Schools and School Library Information Centres
A report from the Canadian Coalition for
School Libraries shows that students who attend schools with
well-funded, properly stocked libraries that offer library programs
managed by qualified staff have higher achievement, improved literacy,
and greater success at the post-secondary level.
The study, entitled "The Crisis in Canada's
School Libraries: The Case for Reform and Reinvestment," was written by
Ken Haycock, professor and former director at the graduate School of
Library, Archival and Information Studies at the University of British
Columbia. According to Haycock, "The evidence is there for all to see.
That's why governments in the U.S., Europe, and Asia are aggressively
investing in their school libraries. What's disturbing is that too many
policymakers are ignoring the findings of literally decades of research
that shows why school libraries and qualified teacher-librarians are
essential components in the academic programming of any school."
The wonderful research and Web sites of such
school library and reading luminaries as Keith Curry Lance, Ken
Haycock, Ross Todd, David Loertscher, Stephen Krashen, and Ray Doiron
are all connected here and continue to track the value of school
library programs and collections. You can read and download the report
at http://www.peopleforeducation.com/librarycoalition/Report03.pdf. You will also find useful links at the School Library Information Portal [http://www.cla.ca/slip/] hosted by the Canadian Library Association. Another useful site is the Ontario Library Association's School Libraries Toolkit [http://www.accessola.com/school%5flib/], along with one provided by AASL at http://www.ala.org/ala/aasl/aaslproftools/toolkits/aasladvocacy.htm.
The Ontario curriculum shows detailed
outcomes for reasoning, organizing, communicating, and applying
information literacy skills by grade level and ties these to the tools
and resources for each level. While we are all aware of the range of
skills and abilities in each grade level, these guidelines are
incredibly valuable in focusing our attention on what deliverables we
want to see in our partnerships between teachers and school libraries
and, indeed, between schools and public libraries. These partnerships
are even more valuable in placing technology and electronic resources
in the appropriate context and perspective in the K-12 curricula.
Public Library Partnerships
There are specific school curriculum markers
that can serve as the skeletal framework for a successful school/public
library partnership--especially if your school doesn't have a full-time
teacher-librarian or enough library staff or volunteers who link the
library program to learning needs and overall curriculum objectives.
Although it's sad when resources are restricted, we can't just throw
our hands in the air and give up. Schools need the ability to serve the
full width and depth of student abilities, and the library--any type of
library, actually--can be the point where our overachieving and
underachieving learners can blossom.
Quite a few librarians in Canada have built
programs that linked public and school libraries. Some have assigned
every librarian a specific grade to contact in their branch's
district--for instance, identify and contact every grade 3 teacher.
They are focused on a specific literacy goal: grade 1 for love of story
time; grade 3 for independent reading; grade 6 for research resources
for their first five-paragraph essay; grade 9 for research resources,
print and electronic for their first major paper; grade 11/12 for
advanced research skills database training. It's a simple scaffolded
approach that builds skills over time and ensures a balance of
resources--print, books, journals, Web, databases, CD-ROM, and film.
Others have started with hospital maternity
wards and offered baskets of books and library cards to new mothers to
get them involved early on. At Toronto Public Library they once went
very BIG. They got the Toronto Blue Jays' 55,000-seat SkyDome facility
and brought in famous Canadian authors, topped with a reading by none
other than J. K. Rowling, and invited all school-age kids. Giving
55,000 people a good impression of the library can't hurt at all! The
Toronto-Dominion Bank sponsors a nationwide summer reading program that
is promoted in the schools before vacation time. CanWest Global, a
national television and media company, sponsors CanSpell and other
reading and literacy activities that are cross promoted in schools and
public libraries. We are not limited by anything other than our own
creativity and ability to take a risk and dream big.
The public library, sometimes through
consortia or statewide purchases, often has electronic resources that
are underused by students. If you haven't visited your public library
and talked to the librarian lately, perhaps it's time for a chat.
Invest an hour in this someday. If you can't get away, most libraries
are open at least some nights or weekends and librarians can be reached
by telephone. Perhaps the best thing you could do this month is to
assign your students this homework task: Obtain a public library
borrower card. (Warn your local library first so they'll be ready for
the onslaught!) Next, show the students how to access the public
library's Web site to identify books or other items like videos,
CD-ROMs, and cassettes that might help them with their projects. (Play
with it yourself if you haven't already; there's a wealth of content
there!) Then, show them the resources they can use in the library or
through the Web with their new cards and that a library card is can be
one of the smartest cards they'll ever own!
And if your community isn't funding its
public library well and the library is consequently providing services
on a shoestring, write a letter. Children and their families deserve
better from their communities. Communities with great library programs
are great communities. If we don't build these relationships now, we
continue to risk having Google and the other search engines control our
kids.
I mentioned above that there is an Ontario curriculum for information literacy from K-12. Here are the citations.
Information Studies, Kindergarten to Grade
12: Curriculum for Schools and School Library Information Centres.
Edited by Tim Gauntley, Rose Dotten, and Liz Kerr. Ontario Library
Association, 1999. 110 p. ISBN 0-88969-040-5 $14.00 CDN
There is also a supplement that comes with
its own CD-ROM: Coded Expectations: A Companion to Information Studies,
Kindergarten to Grade 12, by Angela de Prima. This companion volume is
$17.50 CDN. ISBN 0-88969-046-4. Highlights are available at: http://www.accessola.com/action/positions/info%5fstudies/.
Both can be easily ordered in hardcopy:
Ontario Library Association
100 Lombard Street, Suite 303
Toronto, ON M5C 1M3
416-363-3388 or 1-866-873-9867
FAX: 416-941-9581 or 1-800-387-1181
info@accessola.com
There are important roles for both public and
school libraries to play. Each complements the other and provides a
steppingstone on the path to a life enhanced by reading and
information. You're teaching your learners one of the most important
life skills that can possibly be taught. And, even more, you're helping
to bridge the digital divide--both the economic one and the one that
comes from neglect of teaching information skills. You have the
opportunity to give the gift that lasts a lifetime. Googling isn't
enough! Keep up the good work.
~~~~~~~~
By Stephen Abram
Stephen Abram, M.L.S., is 2004/5
president of the Canadian Library Association and is vice president of
innovation for Sirsi Corp. He would love to hear from you at
stephen.abram@sirsi.com.
Copyright
of MultiMedia & Internet@Schools is the property of Information
Today Inc. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple
sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express
written permission. However, users may print, download, or email
articles for individual use.
Section: STATE CAPITALS
Study Shows Rise in Test Scores Tied to School Library Resources
Students in schools with appropriate and
sufficient library collections and qualified library personnel tend to
perform better on standardized tests, especially in reading, according
to studies of school library programs in Alaska, Colorado, and
Pennsylvania.
Making the school library an integral
learning center and encouraging teachers and librarians to collaborate
on lesson plans and classroom assignments could help raise student
achievement, the report suggests.
"The bottom line across the three states is
that once again, we've shown a positive and statistically significant
correlation between the size of the school library and library media
staff and test scores," said Keith Curry Lance, the director of the
Library Service Center of the Colorado State Library, which conducted
the studies due out next month.
The results mirror those found in the center's 1993 study on school libraries and student achievement in Colorado.
Mr. Lance and his colleagues reviewed surveys
from hundreds of schools in each of the states to gauge staffing
levels, how often students and teachers have access to library
resources and librarians, whether school policies promote usage, and
the technology available in the libraries.
They then compared those responses to state
test results, community demographics, and such school characteristics
as teacher-pupil ratios and teacher qualifications. The researchers
took into account other possible factors influencing achievement on
tests and were able to isolate an added advantage for those with good
library programs.
The reports conclude that test scores
increase as school librarians spend more time collaborating with and
providing training to teachers, providing input into curricula, and
managing information technology for the school.
The full results will be reported in next month's School Library Journal.
Jump in Test Scores
In Colorado, where a representative sample of
200 of 1,178 elementary and middle schools responded, the study found
that state test scores for students in elementary schools with updated
libraries were up to 14 percent higher than for students at schools
with older collections.
Among all the states--in which nearly 850
schools were surveyed altogether--scores on state tests improved by 10
points to 15 points in schools with strong library programs and enough
qualified staff members.
Officials in all three states hope the
results will help convince school administrators that strong libraries
are an important investment.
"This is something our schools can use as
ammunition," said Lois Petersen, the school library coordinator for the
Alaska State Library. "When someone comes in and asks if we can do
without the library, [the librarians] have some research that proves
how important it is."
Added Linda Carvell, the president of the
Pennsylvania association for school librarians: "Linking heightened
scores with library services and information literacy gives some status
to our profession in the education community."
Like many states, Alaska and Pennsylvania do
not require that schools hire library personnel. But advocates have
been pushing for mandates for staffing and stocking school libraries.
~~~~~~~~
By Kathleen Kennedy Manzo
Copyright
of Education Week is the property of Editorial Projects in Education
Inc. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or
posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written
permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for
individual use.
Section: teacher-librarian's perspective
the power of high quality school library programs
The International Federation of Library
Association's (IFLA) Manifesto states: "The school library provides
information and ideas that ore fundamental to functioning successfully
in today's information and knowledge-based society: The school library
equips students with lifelong learning skills and develops the
imagination, enabling them to live as responsible citizens" (2008).
Research clearly supports the role of the
teacher-librarian in ensuring this happens. As early as 1992,
researchers identified an increase in student achievement with high
quality library media programs (1993). Keith Curry Lance et al defines
a high quality media program as one that is adequately staffed,
stocked, and funded; whose staff are actively involved leaders in their
school's teaching and learning enterprise, whose staff have collegial,
collaborative relationships with classroom teachers; and one that
embraces networked information technology. They conclude that, "The
school library is one of the few factors whose contribution to academic
achievement has been documented empirically, and it is a contribution
that cannot be explained away by other powerful influences on student
performance" (2004). Similar research has been replicated in dozen of
States, in Canada (2003,2006) and throughout the world (IASL).
The Research Foundation Paper, School
Libraries Work! (2008), highlights position statements from diverse
groups that have conducted research to show the measurable impact
school libraries and teacher-librarians have on student achievement.
Included is this quote from C. Beth Fitzsimmons, Ph.D., Chairman of the
National Commission on Libraries and Information Science (NCLIS, June,
2007). "From our perspective, a critical part of the comprehensive and
renewed strategy to ensure that students learn to read and are
effective users of information and ideas is the requirement that every
school have a school library and that school libraries be staffed by
highly qualified, state certified, school library media specialists"
(p.2). This article, under the chapter heading "19 States and 1
Province Can't be Wrong," summarizes the research showing the impact of
school libraries and student success.
A recent document, Exemplary School Libraries
in Ontario (Klinger, 2009), not only corroborates these findings but
also looks at the systematic support that is needed to maintain and
promote exemplary school libraries. Without this support in place from
all levels of administration the study acknowledges that
teacher-librarians will leave these positions: "The ad hoc approach to
the role of school libraries in education from the three levels of
administration (school, board and provincial) results in hard won
expertise and knowledge vanishing from the educational system" (p.28).
Further research that focuses on literacy for
the 21st Century emphasizes the need for quality library programs, ones
that establish the teacher-librarian as a leader in integrating the
various forms of text, both print and electronic, that exist today. The
2009 Horizon Report, a qualitative research project that concentrates
on uses of emerging technologies in teaching, learning, research, and
creative expression, highlights the importance of information literacy.
Representatives from an international group of over 300
learning-focused organizations from all disciplines, acknowledge in
their report that information technologies affect how people work,
play, gain information, and collaborate. The authors contend that those
who use technology to make connections globally will advance while
those who do not will find themselves on the sidelines (Johnson, et al
2009). Participatory knowledge is at the center of the online world
where wikis, blogs, and user-generated web sites rule. Students are not
only information consumers but have also become collaborative
information producers, emphasizing the importance of being able to
critically examine information. Our students not only need the
technical skills to be involved in online collaboration but they also
require the communication and social skills to be effective
contributors.
Donald Leu from the New Literacies Research
Lab at the University of Connecticut proposes that students require
additional strategies for reading information online. The assumption
that good print readers will be able to transfer their reading
strengths to online information is incorrect. Leu suggests that there
are different skills at work when one reads online and in fact, poor
print readers often excel when using online resources. It could be that
the smaller chunks of information that appear on the Internet are more
manageable to the less skilled reader or that online help tools and
graphics provide additional clues that assist the reader. The important
fact is that there are new literacies that must be learned to be a
successful user of the Internet. Perhaps the most important ability is
flexibility as students are not mastering a finite set of skills but
rather learning how to learn. Dr. Leu says "…" learning to learn is at
the core of the new literacies. It is not just that we want students to
know how to read and write; we want them to know how to continuously
learn new skills and strategies required by the new technologies of
literacy that will regularly emerge" (2002).
According to Leu, the components of online
reading are: comprehension, question, locate, critically evaluate,
synthesize, and communicate. These components are similar to the models
teacher-librarians use when collaborating with teachers to develop
units of study for their students. As students communicate their
knowledge in different ways they become not only information consumers
but also information producers which intensifies the need for them to
be able to critically evaluate information sources.
The Horizon Report acknowledges emerging
technologies, key trends, and critical challenges that significantly
impact on teaching, learning, creativity, and the greatest challenge
identified as the growing need for further instruction in key new
skills such as information literacy, visual literacy, and technological
literacy. Mitchell Resnick of the Media Laboratory at MIT, describes
literacy as the ability to express meaning to oneself and others. He
acknowledges that new technologies give kids the capacity to
communicate in new ways-including ways that do not entail words. He
feels "words will not vanish from the literacy domain--but literacy
will increasingly be words-with-other-things" (Shore, 2008).
'"Kids are using sound and images so they
have a world of ideas to put together that are not necessarily
language-oriented," said Donna E. Alvermann, a professor of language
and literacy education at the University of Georgia. "Books aren't out
of the picture, but they're only one way of experiencing information in
the world today"' (Rich, 2008). As recognized in the Horizon Report,
visual literacy will become an increasingly important skill in
decoding, encoding, and determining credibility and authenticity of
data.
To be literate in our time requires students
to: be critical thinkers; know how to make sense of various media;
analyze how it can be perceived by different audiences; evaluate it in
terms of other background knowledge; and create then clearly
communicate their ideas to others. Canadian statistics show that over
84.3% of the population uses the Internet with over 90% of those users
accessing email at least weekly (Internet Usage World Stats, 2008).
According to the Nielsen ratings, 72.5% of the United States population
is an Internet user (Internet User World Stats, 2008). An excellent
report on the Google Generation, Information Behavior of the Researcher
of the Future (Nicholas, et al 2007), suggests that more than ever
students require information literacy and at a higher level if they are
to benefit from being part of an information culure. The role of the
teacher-librarian is to ensure that our students understand the
processes and the skills in acquiring new knowledge. We recognize that
students are now both consumers and producers of information and
utilize a variety of online sources for synthesis as well as for
production. We understand the necessity of providing authentic learning
and to inspire literacy in learners of all ages. It would seem that
when requirements for success in our society rests on information
literate citizens, to cut the very jobs that promote information
literacy, would be ill-advised.
REFERENCES
Haycock, K. (2003). The Crisis in Canada's School Libraries: The Case
for Reform and Re-investment. CA: Association of Canadian Publishers.
Rich, M. (2008). Literacy Debate: Online, R U Really Reading? The New York Times. pp. 1, 14, 15. Retrieved on date from http://www.trelease-on-reading.com/r-u-reading.html.
International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions.
(n.d.). "School Libraries and Resource Centers Section." Retrieved
October 19, 2008 from www.ifla.org/VII/s11/pubs/manifest.htm.
International Association of School Libraries. (2008). School libraries
make a difference to student achievement. Retrieved October 19, 2008
from http://www.iasl-online.org/advocacy/make-a-difference.html.
Internet Usage World Stats-Internet and Population Statistics."
Internet Usage World Stats-Internet and Population Statistics.
Retrieved May 20, 2009 from http://ww.internetworldstats.com.
Johnson, L., Levine, A., & Smith, R. (2009). The 2009 Horizon
Report. Austin, Texas: The New Media Consortium. Retrieved on date from
http://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/CSD5612.pdf.
Klinger, D.A. et al. (2009). Exemplary School Libraries in Ontario. Ontario: Ontario Library Association.
Lance, K. C. (2004). Libraries and Student Achievement: The importance
of school libraries. Threshold. [QUERY: Issue date etc.] p.9. Retrieved
on date from www.ciconline.org.
Lance, K. C., Welborn, L., & Hamilton-Pennell, C. (1993). Impact of
School Library Media Centers on Academic Achievement. Castle Rock, CO:
Hi Willow Research and Publishing. Retrieved Oct 19; 2008 from www.lrs.org/lmpact%5fstudy.htm.
Leu, D. (2002). Internet Workshop: Making Time for Literacy. The
Exploring Literacy on the Internet department in Reading Teacher.
Reading Online--The electronic Classroom. Retrieved date from http://www.readingonline.org/electronie/RT/2-02%5fcolumn/
Lonsdale, M. (2003) Impact of school libraries on student achievement: A review of the research. Retrieved Oct 20, 2008 from http://asla.org.au/research/index.htm.
Nicholas, D., Rowlands, I., & Huntington, P. (2008). Information
behaviour of the researcher of the future. A cyber briefing paper.
Retrieved May 13, 2009 from http://www.hisc.ac.uk/media/documents/ programmes/reppres/gg_final_keynote_11012008/pdf.
Rich, M. (2008). Literacy debate: Online, r u really reading? The New York Times, pp. 1, 14, & 15.
Shore, Rima. (2008). The Power of Pow! Wham! Children, Digital Media
& Our Nation's Future-Three Challenges for the Coming Decade.
Retrieved date from http://www.joanganzcooneycenter.org/ pdf/Cooney_Challenge_advance.pdf
The Ontario Library Association. (2006). School libraries and student
achievement in Ontario: A study by Queen's University and People for
Education. Retrieved October 19, 2008 from www.accessola.com.
http://ctell.uconn.edu/canter/canter%5fvideo. cfm?movie=1a_new_technologies.mov
~~~~~~~~
By Michele Farquharson
Michele Farquharson is a
teacher-librarian at Kerrisdale Elementary School in Vancouver, BC,
Michele recently received the Follett International Teacher Librarian
of the Year Award, which is presented in association with the Canadian
Association for School Libraries and honors a school-based
teacher-librarian who has made an outstanding contribution to school
librarianship within Canada. She may be reached at mlf@shaw.ca.
Copyright
of Teacher Librarian is the property of Scarecrow Press Inc. and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a
listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission.
However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual
use.